Skip to content
LAXMI SUNRISE BANK

NEPS: Fee for iPhone, service for Nokia!

अर्थ सरोकार

Kathmandu. There is only one place to buy and sell shares in Nepal—the Nepal Stock Exchange (NEPSE). In other words, investors have two options: NEPSE, or opt out of trading. And this privatization of NEPSE has become the ‘evergreen song’ of our budget speeches—it plays in Parliament every Jestha 15th, and as the month of Saun approaches, no one even remembers the tune.

Announcements were made in many budgets, and government committees formed for capital market reforms also made strong recommendations. Give a certain percentage of NEPSE’s shares to international strategic partners, so that new technology, new thinking, and efficient management come with them. This is common practice on stock exchanges worldwide.

But our announcement is fresh every year, implementation is stale every year—like lentils kept in the fridge, reheated and reserved year after year. If the word ‘privatization’ had been read as many times in the budget speech as it had been implemented, NEPSE would have gone private at least three times by now.

Who’s the owner? Government, government, and government again

Figure 1: NEPSE’s current ownership structure

Source: NEPSE Annual Report.

NEPSE’s paid-up capital is 1 billion rupees. Of this, 58.66 percent is held by the Government of Nepal, 11.23 percent by the National Commercial Bank, 10 percent by the Employees’ Savings Fund, and 9.51 percent by Nepal Rastra Bank. Combining these four, about 89 percent ownership comes into the hands of the government or institutions affiliated with the government. The remaining shares are 5 percent each from Laxmi Bank and Prabhu Bank, and 0.60 percent from others.

In other words, in NEPSÉ, the “private” thing is like pickles on a rice platter—there is, but not the main course; And that’s half a spoonful. The house belongs to the government, the kitchen belongs to the government, the government pays the cook, and the same government that listens to complaints about “Why isn’t the food good?”

Hen laying golden eggs

Figure 2: NEPSCO dividend (%) and earnings per share (EPS) by fiscal year

Source: NEPSE Annual Report.

In terms of profit, NEPSE truly is a golden egg-laying hen. Between fiscal year 2075/76 and 2081/82, it distributed an average dividend of 83 percent, an average earnings per share of 120 rupees, and a net profit margin of 54 percent. In fiscal year 2077/78, a 167 percent dividend and an EPS of 235 rupees! If a private company CEO arrived at a board meeting carrying such a report card, they would leave with applause and garlands.

After seeing such statistics, it’s natural to ask: why hand over such a well-made company to private or foreign hands? “Nationalist” friends immediately chime in—”Selling a chicken that lays golden eggs? Absolutely not!” The government has no desire to face accusations that it “sold the gold company and ate it.”

But this is where economics asks a deeper question: is the chicken laying eggs through its own effort, or is there no other chicken in the coop? If a solo runner wins gold, the medal is real, but the race is fake.

The secret of profit: not hard work, but monopoly

NEPSE is the country’s only stock exchange. There is neither a competitor nor an alternative. Listing fees, transaction fees, and various other fees (some invisible to the naked eye)—companies and investors have no choice but to pay. After gaining a monopoly in the service sector, profit comes not from strategy but from the obligation to say “there is only one way.” Therefore, considering NEPSE’s high EPS, dividends, and net profit margins as proof of management efficiency is like a lone shopkeeper in the village proudly saying, “My shop is doing the best.” When there is no other store in the village, where are customers to run from? And the service? While the world’s stock markets race with new products, new technologies, and new services, Nepse is still moving slowly. Software and websites even occasionally go on vacation. In short: the fee is for the iPhone, the service for Nokia.

The system freezes in the middle of a transaction—the order appears to have gone through, but no execution is visible. The investor keeps staring at the screen, the price races at its own pace, and is forced to sit with their hands tied. You can’t buy, sell, or exit. And the answer is the same, always the same—”technical problem.” ” These two words are Nepse’s most reliable product: they never go down. Whether the problem is technical or systemic, it’s now up to the investor to distinguish.

‘Government work, when does the sun come on’

Institutions holding majority shares in the government follow the tightrope of prescribed procedures and rules. But in a rapidly changing business environment, when and how quickly decisions are made, and government institutions lag behind here. You don’t have to look far for evidence: compare the performance of public sector banks like the National Commercial Bank or Nepal Bank to private banks, and the difference is obvious. Private institutions appear more effective, faster, and more innovative.

Now, the story of the employee. NEPSÉ employees are selected through the Public Service Commission. (When you add the initials of the public service, it becomes “lose”—just like the name, the appointed employees are the same, and the same made NEPSÉ like themselves, the elders called it the fruit according to the company, is that it!) । Even the lowest-level employees at NEPSE receive good salaries, permanent jobs, promotion opportunities through public service exams, festivals, education, study and sick allowance, and even pensions. In the private sector, these benefits often come only in dreams, yet productivity is still high.

Once you get a job in a government institution, firing someone is as difficult as moving Mount Everest. Once there’s no fear of losing the job, the pace of work starts to move to the rhythm of ‘government work, when the sun shines.’ The fault lies more with the system than with the individual; Even a fine seed cannot bear fruit if planted in the sand. Therefore, solutions must also be found within the system: reducing government shares, bringing in international partners, and handing management over to the private sector—with full authority over hiring and firing employees, just like in the private sector.

Board of Directors: Heart Operation to the Kidney Surgeon

NEPSE’s board of directors includes 8 members, including the Chief Executive Officer and the company secretary. Of the remaining 6, 2 are from the Ministry of Finance, 2 from Nepal Rastra Bank, 1 from the National Commercial Bank, and a total of 1 independent. Of the six, five are from government houses, only one is “independent”—like five groom’s family and only one bride’s side at the wedding feast.

These officials from the Ministry of Finance, Rastra Bank, and Commercial Bank may hold high status in their positions, but how familiar they are with the stock market and its regulations is another question. It’s like assigning a civil engineer to work as a mechanical engineer, or sending a heart surgeon to perform kidney surgery. Every field has its own reality; one cannot forcibly hand over work to another. No matter how big the surgeon is, the patient’s fate after stabbing the wrong organ is God’s fate.

On top of that, they have their own institutions and responsibilities. It’s just as hard to hope that Nepsey will be given full-time. On the board of directors, professionals who have done real work in the stock market and understand the market should be in the majority—not someone with little knowledge of the field.

Why does privatization get stuck? Is the answer hidden in the “allowance”?

The board of directors receives a good “allowance.” Therefore, officials of the relevant bodies are eager to be represented in NEPSE, whether or not there is a full-time commitment. Isn’t this the answer to why the Ministry of Finance and related bodies show no interest in privatization despite numerous committee recommendations and government announcements? Who would kick themselves in the stomach! After privatization, the number of such representatives decreases, and professionals take that spot.

There was an old saying—”Whose power is his devotion.” In the context of Nepse, the new version might be—”Whose allowance is his power.”

The committee formed by the previous government had released a report recommending bringing in strategic partners, reducing government ownership, and improving good governance, and the regulatory body was also engaged in discussions. But in our system, we have a tradition of rewarding those who write reports, respecting those who understand, and resting the file in a drawer.

On top of that, the current government is busy giving breathing room to shuttered industries. The market itself is skeptical that the government, about to revive a dead chicken, will get it out of the coop that is laying golden eggs. Now whether this report will change NEPS’s face or just add to the dust in the drawer remains to be seen.

Conclusion: A big slice of a small cake or a small piece of a big cake?

What the government needs to understand is straightforward: privatization reduces the government’s ownership percentage, but it makes the institution effective, innovative, and dynamic. Even a small slice of a big cake can be much more than a big slice of a small cake—after all, the government’s revenue is also greater than current holdings.

If the government doesn’t want to give up shares, at least let management go: the private sector is responsible for staff recruitment and running the institution, with zero interference. Keep the chickens yourself, but give the keys to the coop to those who know how to keep chickens. Otherwise, let’s be ready to hear the announcement of NEPSE’s privatization in the next budget—the same old song, the same old tune.

– Dipendra Pandey’s article

Hamro Patro Remit

प्रतिक्रिया दिनुहोस्

GARIMA BIKAS BANK